Are you confused between CycleOps Magneto vs Fluid 2? Below, you can read the detailed comparison between these two bike trainers. Although they come from the same company and seem to be similar, there are actually several important differences that set them apart. CycleOps Magneto is a decent model, but CycleOps Fluid 2 is better for a dedicated cyclist.
Continue reading below to learn further about:
– The size and weight of each bike trainer here
– The compatibility of CycleOps Magneto and CycleOps Fluid 2
– The resistance unit of CycleOps Magneto vs Fluid 2
– The noise and performance comparison of the two models
– The warranty of each model
– Which bike trainer that is generally better
Size and Weight
Unlike CycleOps Jet Fluid Pro which we discussed in a previous article take a look at CycleOps Jet Fluid Pro vs Fluid 2, the two bike trainers in our focus this time don’t fold flat. They can be folded, but they won’t become completely flat. Still, they are fairly compact and space-friendly.
Each model here measures 17.9 inches x 13.4 inches x 10.4 inches. The weight of each model is about 27.1 pounds. CycleOps Magneto and CycleOps Fluid 2 have the classic frame which is spring loaded and equipped with a bolt action lever for easy folding and unfolding. Indeed, these bike trainers are rather heavy, which may be a slight issue when you need to lift them up.
When not in use, you can fold either bike trainer into a fairly compact form. This also enables you to fit the bike trainer into your car’s trunk when necessary. Although CycleOps Magneto and CycleOps Fluid 2 can’t fold flat, they are not too large in the first place, so they are still quite portable and manageable.
Set-up and Compatibility
Both CycleOps Magneto vs Fluid 2 are quite easy to set up. They will come in some parts that you need to assemble on your own. However, they both come with their respective manuals. The instructions are easy to understand. You should have no problem in assembling and setting up either bike trainer. The entire assembly process takes only several minutes.
Each of the two models is equipped with adjustable footpads. By adjusting the footpads, you can ensure a stable performance regardless of the surface condition. A sturdy clamp will keep your bike steadily in place. In addition, each model here also has a clutch knob that will ensure the right tension between the resistance unit and the rear wheel. The clutch knob will give an audible click when the right tension is achieved, so you will always know for sure.
CycleOps Magneto and CycleOps Fluid 2 have similar compatibility. They both are compatible with a wide range of road bikes and mountain bikes. So, most probably, your bike can fit on both models as well, but continue reading to make sure.
Each bike trainer here comes with a steel quick-release skewer which is very sturdy and durable with three selectable settings for rear dropout spacing: 135mm, 130mm, and 120mm. Furthermore, they each have an optional thru-axle adapter which can fit 142x12mm bikes as well as 148x12mm bikes. Thanks to the quick-release mechanism, getting your bike on and off will be easy.
Both models can be used with 26-inch, 27-inch, 29-inch, 650b, and 700c wheel sizes. However, keep in mind that they only allow a maximum tire width of 2.0 inches. You can’t fit thicker tires in. Both models can work with the company’s specially designed trainer tires, which are said to be extremely quiet and very durable. CycleOps Magneto and CycleOps Fluid 2 have a similar total weight capacity, which is 300 lbs including both the rider and the bike.
The biggest difference between CycleOps Magneto vs Fluid 2 is the resistance unit. CycleOps Magneto is based on a progressive magnetic mechanism, whereas CycleOps Fluid 2 runs on a fluid-based mechanism.
CycleOps Magneto has an adjustable magnetic resistance which functions to create a dragging force against the wheel of the bike. It also has a flywheel as a drive mechanism that rotates the magnets and creates resistance as the magnets are engaged and disengaged. The precision-balanced flywheel is made from a zinc alloy to ensure the durability.
In traditional magnetic trainers, you need to get down in order to change the resistance level. However, CycleOps Magneto comes with a special mechanism that allows the resistance to become progressively harder as you pedal the bike. This allows the trainer to deliver a more realistic performance.
CycleOps Fluid 2, on the other hand, has a fluid-based resistance unit. It also has a flywheel to drive the wheel of the bike. This large precision-balanced flywheel has been optimized to provide an optimum road-like feel. However, the resistance is actually generated by an impeller which spins the fluid inside the flywheel. The fluid will become thicker as the temperature rises. So, the faster and longer you pedal, the more challenging the resistance will become.
One special feature that sets CycleOps Fluid 2 apart from other fluid-based trainers is the self-cooling mechanism. It has a patented fan design which enables the flywheel to perform much longer without getting overheated. This also ensures a smooth resistance increase and excellent consistency.
When choosing between CycleOps Magneto vs Fluid 2, you may also want to consider about the noise. If you have other people living in the same home, or if there are neighbors in close proximity, you probably prefer a bike trainer that is quiet.
CycleOps Magneto tends to be a little bit more noisy than CycleOps Fluid 2, but the difference is not that much. This model has a noise rating of 66 – 68 decibels when running at 20 mph. It will not disturb your neighbors for sure.
CycleOps Fluid 2 tends to be slightly quieter. It has a noise rating of 64 – 68 decibels when running at 20 mph. As a comparison, the noise of a normal conversation is about 60 decibels. So, this bike trainer is fairly quiet, and it won’t disturb other family members or neighbors.
In general, both CycleOps Magneto and CycleOps Fluid 2 have excellent performance. However, still, CycleOps Magneto is not as good as CycleOps Fluid 2.
CycleOps Magneto is fairly smooth and quiet. The resistance gradually increases without any noticeable friction or vibration. However, it is not as smooth as CycleOps Fluid 2. In addition, the challenges that it can offer are not really challenging. It is good enough for beginners and casual users. But if you are a dedicated cyclist and you want to improve your power, you need a more powerful trainer.
CycleOps Fluid 2 is really smooth, and it is also really quiet. It is able to increase the resistance very smoothly so that you almost don’t notice it. Thanks to the PowerTuned technology, this bike trainer can deliver a convincing road-like feel. And the self-cooling mechanism is really useful for extensive training sessions.
Compared to its sibling, CycleOps Fluid 2 can be quite more challenging. The fluid-based unit can deliver a great amount of resistance, and the self-cooling mechanism will allow you to challenge yourself for an extended time.
Although these bike trainers are not equipped with computers or sensors, you can still use them with virtual training apps like Rouvy and Zwift. You just need to set up a speed sensor on your bike (you can also add a power meter or heart rate strap, though these sensors are optional). Download and install the desired virtual training app on your desired platform. Then, connect the speed sensor, and select the trainer model. You are ready to go.
Last but not least, whenever you are about to buy a bike trainer, don’t forget to check the warranty. Although CycleOps is known to produce excellent quality items, you always want to have a good and reliable warranty. Both CycleOps Magneto and CycleOps Fluid have different warranty policies depending on whether they are used for home/personal purpose or commercial purpose.
For home/personal use, the frame is backed for a lifetime. It guarantees that there will be no weld breakage. Note that the finish and decals are not covered by the warranty. Meanwhile, the resistance unit is backed for 2 years.
For commercial use, the frame is only backed for 5 years. Similarly, the finish and decals are not included in the warranty. However, it also does not cover the resistance unit. So, since the resistance unit is not warrantied in this situation, you should make sure that the bike trainer is not abused.
In either case, the warranty won’t cover some of the smaller parts, such as the clutch knob, bolts, rollers, and feet. The warranty will become void if the unit is improperly assembled, improperly maintained, or modified. The company will provide a replacement for a product or part that is found to be defective within the terms.
CycleOps Magneto vs Fluid 2
CycleOps Fluid 2 is generally more recommended. It comes with a better resistance unit. It is fluid-based, so the performance tends to be smoother and a little bit quieter. In addition, it can deliver heavier challenges for dedicated users.